Celebrating Eclipses

Gogineni, Babu (2)IndiaWorld-wide

Eclipses down the ages

The apparent rising and setting of the sun and the Northern Lights are amongst the most captivating natural sights one can enjoy with the naked eye – it almost matches the joy of looking at a smiling human baby. Countless poets and artists immortalised their rapture at witnessing these natural phenomena.

But how people reacted to eclipses is a different story: as the sun or the moon inexplicably appeared to be devoured by something, people were terrified of them. In the Assyrian and the Babylonian cultures lunar eclipses were seen as evil omens; in ancient Greece solar eclipses were dreaded. Here is a fragment of a lost poem by the Greek Archilochus writing of the Total Solar Eclipse of 6 April 648 BCE. 

“Zeus, father of the Olympians, made night from mid-day, hiding the light of the shining Sun, and sore fear came upon men”.

About 2000 years later, things were still the same in Europe! John Milton captures the fears of the ages when he writes of a solar eclipse in his ParadiseLost (1650)

Shorn of his beams, or from behind the Moon,
In dim eclipse, disastrous twilight sheds
On half the nations and with fear of change
Perplexes monarchs.

Predicting eclipses
Several hundreds of years of dread and observation made it possible for the Chaldeans, who, living in what is today’s Southern Iraq, perfected around 600 BCE the science of eclipse prediction. A famous story is told of Thales, the pre-Socratic Greek Philosopher from Asia Minor (Turkey), who based himself on the Chaldean calculation of saros and accurately predicted the Total Solar Eclipse of 28 May 585 BC. A saros is the calculation that similar eclipses of the sun recur in cycles of 18 years, 11 1/3 days (or 6585.3 days), because it takes that long for the sun, the earth, and the moon to return to nearly identical relative positions. Few took notice of Thales’ prediction then, but when the eclipse came, the two warring nations of Lydians and Medes were so startled that they stopped their 5-year war and signed an urgent peace treaty!

From calendars to understanding the Universe
Perhaps the first to have advanced beyond calendar-making to an understanding of the universe through watching an eclipse was the great Indian mathematician and astronomer Aryabhatta (476–550 CE) who watched a solar eclipse and proposed at the age of 23 his Heliocentric theory, a thousand years before the Polish Copernicus (1473 – 1543). Aryabhatta proposed that the moon caused the solar eclipse by blocking the sun, and that the moon only reflects light, just like the other planets.

The next time a solar eclipse led to a great discovery was again in India when, on 18 August 1868 in Guntur town near Vijayawada, through a spectroscopic study of the sun’s corona at the time of totality, European scientists discovered the presence of a new element: Helium. Helium is formed in the sun through nuclear fusion of hydrogen atoms, releasing the life sustaining energy that reaches the earth.

The total solar eclipse that is the most memorable in the history of science is that of 29 May 1919. Einstein’s 1915 General Theory of Relativity postulates that space could be distorted by gravity. If that were right, the sun’s massive gravity could bend even light rays towards itself. During totality, the scientist Eddington and his colleagues observed that light from the cluster of bright stars Hyades seen just behind the sun appeared to bend towards the sun. Einstein was proved right and Newton’s Theory of Gravity was replaced by the more correct Theory of General Relativity!

Not just for the scientists!
Eclipses come in all shapes and forms: there are solar and lunar eclipses, and they could be either partial or total.

A solar eclipse occurs when the moon comes between the earth and the sun, thus blocking the sun from the earth, sometimes partially, sometimes completely, sometimes only the centre leaving the edges of the sun exposed – called an annular eclipse, like that of January 15, 2010.

A lunar eclipse occurs when the earth blocks the sunlight from falling on the moon. As the moon does not emit light of its own and only reflects sunlight like a badly polished mirror (the moon reflects 7 percent of the light that falls on it, the earth reflects 39 percent), when sunlight is prevented from falling on the moon, it appears dark, like most other things in space.

Watching the awe inspiring Total Solar Eclipse

There are at least two lunar and two solar eclipses every year, somewhere on the earth. While it is true that an eclipse is just the play of light and shadow, a Total Solar Eclipse can be spectacular.

As the eclipse approaches totality, darkness descends rapidly and we see the fast moving shadow of the moon as shadow bands, because of atmospheric interference. Birds start returning to their nests to roost, and the animals are confused. It is an eerie feeling as twilight falls, the horizon line acquires a glow, shadows sharpen and darken, and one feels emboldened to look up and see the sun. And as the sun rapidly disappears, just moments before totality, sunlight peeking through one of the moon’s deepest craters creates the spectacular effect of the diamond ring.

On 24 October 1995 I was in Agra, where the Taj Mahal is located, to watch the Total Solar Eclipse. All of Agra town was huddled inside, fearing the evils an eclipse may bring. A few of us – a couple of hundred science enthusiasts – were perched on the ramparts of the historic Agra Fort to catch the eclipse. As totality approached, when the diamond ring revealed itself, there was a loud and collective gasp from all those who were there – and one of my new friends said “Now it doesn’t matter if I lose my eyesight. I have seen the most magnificent thing possible!” So overwhelming was the feeling of seeing our life giver, majestically perched in the sky in all his glory that it makes one almost irrational.

Catch it Before it is Too Late!
The sun is 400 times farther from the earth than the moon. And the moon’s size is almost 400 times smaller than the sun: so from the earth both the sun and the moon appear to be almost of the same size: this is what makes our solar eclipses possible.

However, as tidal acceleration is causing the Moon to move away from the earth by about 3.8 cms each year, and as the sun is steadily growing larger in size, in 600 million years the moon would have moved so far away from the earth (23 thousand kilometers) and the sun grown in size, that total solar eclipses will no longer be possible on the earth.

So watch them while you can!

Eclipses call for more special celebrations than New Years and Solstices. Write a poem, draw a painting, or have a meal to celebrate the celestial chiaroscuro non pareil!

 

How Astrologers, Hooligans and the Police Spoilt our Celebrations on

15 January 2010

The Disaster at Eclipse Time

Maybe it is right that eclipses bring disasters: otherwise how can we explain the presence of astrologers in TV studios spouting nonsense about impending doom?

Like in the ancient civilisations in the Americas, in Egypt and in Babylonia, the people of China and India had no real clue about how eclipses occurred. They believed that eclipses occurred when dragons and monsters devoured the sun or the moon. They hid indoors. They made loud noises to scare the dragons away.

Even today, in the Indian sub-continent where 1/6 of humanity lives, it is as if Aryabhatta, Copernicus and Galileo were never born! It is as if over 60 years ago the pregnant Saraswati Gora and her associates never chopped vegetables in Vijayawada to show that no harm would come to her or the foetus: she lived up to a grand old age, and all her children are accomplished and noted public personalities!

Afraid of the Moon’s Shadow

Perched in TV studios, astrologers continue to advise pregnant women to stay indoors as ‘special rays’ are emitted during eclipse time. With their half baked knowledge of geology and magnetism, astrologers claim that eclipses cause disastrous earthquakes, that gravitation will change the course of human life etc. In one TV discussion I was outraged by an astrologer’s claim that their prayers would help the sun liberate himself from the monster Rahu! He advised purificatory baths after the eclipse. In India, which sent a satellite to the moon, people are still scared of the moon’s shadow!

To fight against this ignorance and national humiliation, science popularisation groups, rationalists, Humanists and atheists have been conducting public education programs, notably the Jana Vignana Vedika which has a large reach, the Atheist Centre in Vijayawada, the Dalit Humanist groups like Spoorthy and Disha, and local planetariums. As part of such activities IHEU’s MO Manava Vikasa Vedika (MVV) organised a get together for communal viewing of the eclipse and celebration of the event with good food in Hyderabad. Elsewhere, the Humanist Dalit leader Veeraswamy and his pregnant wife cooked food in public during the eclipse. Meanwhile, in Hyderabad, at the MVV’s tent a large number of people gathered to celebrate. A pregnant lady member of the group started cutting an apple saying she does not believe that her foetus would be affected.

What is an apple’s religion?

Suddenly, a group of Hindu fundamentalists came, aggressively protesting that they would file a case of attempt to murder as the foetus would be affected! ‘You chose to cut an apple which is not an Indian fruit. It is indicative of your foreign religion’, one of them said on live TV.

My day had started that day at 8 in the morning at INews TV Channel in their popular ICafe program talking about the eclipse for a 30 minute interview. It was followed immediately by a 2 hour stint in the highest TRP rated channel network in India, TV9, where I was commenting along with the anchor as the eclipse progressed  – and arguing with some astrologers as they came online.

By the time I was called back to INews in the afternoon for an hour’s discussion along with fellow rationalist and Humanist Gopala Rao and an astrologer, the Hindu fundamentalists had their way. The police had to be called in who, in their natural wisdom, disrupted the gathering, pulled down the tent, and took away MVV’s General Secretary for Hyderabad, popularly known as KVR, to the police station. KVR’s hand was violently twisted, he was dumped into a three wheeler, beaten by the sub-Inspector of Police with the kind comment that if he wanted to watch the eclipse he had to do it from his home and not from the road.

The police were right that no permission was taken to organise a public meeting, but did not arrest any of the hooligans, almost as though they approved of the aggression. I was later in Mahaa TV for a 30 minute discussion with the studio anchor where I asked if the special harmful rays had a way of identifying the pregnant Hindus and affecting them as Muslims and Christians and indeed livestock seem quite unaffected.

Thanks to the astrologers my day was spent in four TV channels being on air for a total of four useful hours – as most people were indoors many watched TV and heard our arguments. But I did have one regret – I could not watch the eclipse myself! That regret became less intense as one started meeting countless strangers at the ATM, in the street and in restaurants:  some said they did not throw away cooked food after the eclipse as they were convinced by us. Whatever residual regrets there were disappeared completely with a phone call from a stranger - a full 2 months after the eclipse.

‘My sister is doing well’

“Sir, I went through a lot of trouble to get your phone number. I wanted to thank you but the TV stations would not give it…I am a Hindu but what you say is right and we are changing – but some of my friends refuse to watch because they say you will convince them. You won’t believe this, but on 15 January, Solar Eclipse Day, my pregnant sister went into labour but my family refused to take her to the hospital saying going out during eclipse is dangerous for the foetus. So I made my people watch my recording of your morning program, and they also watched you on TV9 live during the eclipse. They finally agreed. At the nursing home after she was admitted I bought refreshments for 20 patients and we all ate together and watched your program. Nothing happened to us, or to my sister or her newborn child”.

 

(Readers may obtain a pdf version of 'Celebrating Eclipses', an illustrated booklet in English by Babu Gogineni, by sending a request to gogineniatiheu [dot] org. The booklet looks at the cultural beliefs and the science around eclipses. –Ed.)

 

Babu Gogineni

Trackback URL for this post:

http://www.iheu.org/trackback/4018